What is the ideal form of government according to aristotle aristocracy o a few good citizens ruling the government with the best interest of the people in mind. In comparing the good citizen and the good human being, aristotle states, as to the question whether the excellence of the good man is the same as that of the good citizen, the consideration already adduced prove that in some states the good man and the good citizen are the same, and in others different, depending on the form of. According to aristotle, citizens were all who share in the civic life of ruling and being ruled in turn citizenship in the city-states was a status granted only to certain groups, depending on the form of government. According to plato, the ideal city had to be an enlightened one, one based on the highest universal principles he insisted that only individuals who were committed to these truths, who could protect and preserve them for the sake of the common good, were fit to rule the city. The ideal is the state in which the best, who are inevitably few in number, exercise power in the interests of all however, since that ideal is hard to achieve, and even harder to sustain, aristotle advocated a form of mixed government, or politeia, in which all citizens rule and are ruled by turn, and power is monopolized by no particular.
But even under this system of government, the people would have a greater say than under most systems of indirect democracy: in aristotle's ideal state, when the kings introduce business in the assembly, they do not merely let the people sit and listen to the decisions that have been taken by their rulers, but the people have the sovereign. Thus,in his republic plato gives the theory of an ideal statebut later the theory of the ideal state was severely criticized by aristotle email this blogthis share to twitter share to facebook. In the politics, aristotle rejected plato's ideal state he said that it fails to address conflicts that will arise among its citizens he said that it fails to address conflicts that will arise among its citizens. Aristotle on democracy and government of any state is said by us to be a citizens of that state aristotle politics features on democracy in ancient greece.
History of citizenship describes the changing as an ideal state, greeks thought that being a citizen was a natural state, according to j g. When we consider that aristotle's ideal state must be limited in size and that his middle class would be one composed solely of citizens, a term with distinct limitations compared to how it is used in a modern democracy. Aristotle's notion of justice and other issues first, a question about whether aristotle can apply to us today aristotle explicitly says at 1326a that the statesperson ought to consider the size of the ideal state, and he clearly says that a very populous state cannot be well-governed.
What is the form of the ideal state, according to plato what is the form of the ideal state for aristotle it gives citizens a right to revolt if the. What were the government ideals for the socrates and aristotle kings should lead city-states in a sort of oligarchical system the first citizen of. Theory of human nature: in contrast to the state of virtue in thinking about the ideal life, aristotle contrasts lives of pleasure, honor, and intellectual.
Political institution, and its end was to promote among its citizens goodness and justice, the latter representing an ideal perfection in human relationships(bhandari,2002) this part deals with the theories of plato and aristotle as follows. Aristotle on constitutions and the best constitution according to aristotle, the two most common ideas of justice are inadequate, yet the claims of each cannot be. Aristotle, unlike plato, drew a distinction between a good man and a good citizen, and this distinction would have a profound influence on later philosophy according to aristotle, our common nature as human beings generates a concept of the good man that applies to everyone, so aristotle agreed with plato that in an ideal state there would be. Education in the ideal state aristotle's classification after studying a number of real and theoretical city-state's constitutions, aristotle classified them according to various criteria. Aristotle's ethics and politics: happiness, reason and the ideal society aristotle allows the citizens of his state to have much more say than plato does.
Hence, an ideal state must be a state that is based on a perfected standard plato and aristotle both prescribed what these perfected standards on which the state be based, should be, according to their metaphysical orientation about man. The ideal state: plato versus aristotle description: for plato, the ideal state is a natural aristocracy ruled by a class of aristocracy, and polity, while the bad are tyranny, oligarchy, and democracy. Aristotle is a towering figure in it is in the constitution that the good person and the good citizen coincide ideal to serve this end the ideal state should. Polis indicates an ancient town which is also the state aristotle when, according to the rules of aristotle says that it is ideal, but the poorest citizens.
Citizens in democracies rule and are ruled in turn according to aristotle prudence or practical wisdom is the most important virtue for aristotle. On the purpose of the state: continuity and change in political theories according to aristotle, sacrifice individual citizens to the state according to. According to aristotle, a good citizen upholds and respects the constitution he claims, a good citizen should know and have the capacity both to be ruled and to rule (aristotle, 92) in the republic, socrates gives three waves that he believes are necessary to achieve justice in an unhealthy city.